Carl Mark Force was not a poor man. Many would be happy making $150,000 a year, but not DEA investigator Carl Mark Force. He wanted money and that got him into trouble. Then, he wanted to cover up the fact that he wanted money, and that got him into even more trouble. The documents that have recently come available, some leaked and others not, paint a very complicated and sometimes bizarre story which I will try to simplify as much as possible. In fact, the simplest way to look at this case is to imagine the kid in the empty candy store scenario. If you leave a kid in an empty candy store, how long will it be before the kid has to sample some of the products? Carl Mark Force’s candy store happened to be the riches available on the Silk Road, and he simply could not resist the temptation to take some for himself. But let me trace the path that led Force into this position.
Carl Mark Force
Force was tasked with gaining access to the inner workings of the underground, deep web marketplace known as the Silk Road. This site had been a thorn in the DEA’s side for a long time because the site, flaunting all DEA regulations, made all sorts of illegal drugs available to buyers 24/7. The fact that the site used the identity-protecting Tor browser and untraceable bitcoins made it impossible to penetrate. It was, therefore, concluded that the only way into it was to gain the confidence of the site’s operators and work from there. That’s what Carl Force did. He pretended to be a major international drug dealer under the DEA-approved persona of ‘Nob’ and, in fact, managed to gain the trust of site owner, Dread Pirate Roberts (DPR), later to be identified as Ross Ulbricht.
Eventually, the DEA used Force’s connections to set up a sting operation on one of Ulbricht’s associates, first identified by the initials, C.G. but, in later documents, named as Curtis Green (a.k.a “Flush” and “chronicpain”).
Green apparently offered little resistance when confronted and quickly agreed to help the DEA in its investigation for promises of leniency. This is where the DEA got a break. Green had administrative rights on the site, which meant he could change the passwords and pin numbers of any user account. He had full control of any account he wanted. He gave this information to the DEA and Force and, for Force, this was the key to the candy store.
Force now found himself in control of every account on Silk Road. A week later, the Silk Road was hit with the theft of over $350,000. It could have been more if one of Ulbricht’s associates, “Inigo”(later identified as Andrew Michael Jones) hadn’t discovered it in progress and stopped it. Inigo traced the theft to Green. At least that was the login that the action seemed to be coming from. When Ulbricht found out, he was furious because he felt he had been betrayed. Neither Ulbricht nor Inigo could believe that Green could have done such a thing. It was a stupid thing to do because they knew Green’s real address in Utah. Ulbricht required this for his own protection in case one of his close associates betrayed him. In the recently leaked transcripts of conversations found on Ulbricht’s computer, Inigo states, “as far as I can tell it was flush (Green), and he managed to steal a little over $350k either that or somebody with access to his account but my hunch is that it was him.” Ulbricht later comments to Force (acting as Nob), “this will be the first time I have had to call on my muscle.”
This part of the story is a bit hazy. It is not yet clear who stole this money. It could have been another agent, also now under arrest, named Shaun Bridges. Both had access to Green’s account if they wanted it. It is also not clear how much Force and Bridges knew of each other’s illegal activity or, for that matter, how much they knew each other. We do know they communicated and the trial may show that they worked this angle together. In any event, one or both of these agents were in the process of emptying accounts and locking out their owners, probably by changing their passwords, when they were stopped. Ironically enough, Inigo stopped them from stealing more money by changing the password on the account they were using. That certainly must have been aggravating.
Ulbricht felt betrayed and angry. After all, Green had been a friend. Mostly, he wanted his money back. He figured he could simply threaten Green and get him to return the money. “I’d like him beat up, then forced to send the bitcoins he stole back. Like sit him down at his computer and make him do it beat up only if he doesn’t comply I guess not sure how these things usually go.” To me, it seems, at least initially, that Force tries to push Ulbricht into taking more extreme action. Nob is willing to help in this and says he can hire someone. Ulbricht thinks it’s a good idea but only if it costs less than the money that has been stolen. Conveniently, Force may have already known how much was stolen, so he could have had an idea of what to charge Ulbricht for his services.
You might think that Ulbricht would be suspicious about Force, but in another conversation with a woman named, Cimon, he states, “yea, nobs legit, but not quite as big time as he was making himself out to be”. In other conversations, it appears Force, as Nob, was hinting that he was connected with Columbian drug lords and FARC.
As Cimon and Ulbricht continue to chat, the two are also confused on how Green could have been arrested on a cocaine bust but then suddenly be stealing money out of people’s accounts. Cimon remarks, seemingly perplexed, “so he ain’t in jail and his computer wasn’t taken so the feds have no(t) linked there. Yet. He still has lots of time to deal.” To which Ulbricht responds with, “so he must be out on bail? He might be fleeing.” Cimon comments, “facing a serious felony he’s def the kind of guy that would seel (sell) what little he knows for a break with the Feebs (FBI).”
After some thought and more conversations with Cimon (who definitely pushes for killing Green) and Inigo on what to do, Ulbricht has the following chat with Force on the day after the theft:
Ulbricht: never killed a man or had one killed before, but it is the right move in this case. How much will it cost?
Nob: ok, I was going to pay $5,000 to have him beat up; I need to contact my associate and ask what the price will be for the deed
Ulbricht: ok ballpark?
Nob: i have no idea what it will cost
Ulbricht: ok less than $100k?
Nob: depends, they need to check out the neighborhood, police force, etc.
Ulbricht: have you killed or had someone killed before?
Nob: i’m a good catholic man, but yes I have; sometimes there are no alternatives
Later, Force checks in via chat with information about the hit on Green.
Nob: my guy got back to me at quoted 80K for the hit; guy lives in a tight neighborhood; going to be hard gettin in and the body out
Nob: you want to go forward? i assume you are going to want to move fast
Ulbricht: yes, let’s do it
And so the plan for Force to eliminate Green was put in place.
Curtis Green was killed around February 19, 2013, or so Ulbricht thought. The DEA, with Green’s help, staged a fake killing and sent photos to Ulbricht. The $80,000 was sent into a DEA account. One can imagine what Ulbricht’s state of mind must have been in at this time. He had had his site repeatedly attacked by hackers, the DEA, and other law enforcement agencies, which alone must have kept him in a permanent paranoiac state. Now, he had just been deceived by someone he trusted and had lost a lot of money on top of it. Worse yet, he was now implicated in a murder. Sure, he had gotten rid of Green and, perhaps, had sent a signal to other would-be con artists that they should be careful if they tried to cross him. However, he now had another weak spot, and that was Nob. Nob was the only one who could really connect him to the Green hit. Both he and Force must have known this. Power in the relationship had shifted. Force must have realized he could now find other ways to get money from Ulbricht if that was his goal. On his side, Ulbricht must have realized that he had no choice but to keep Nob happy. In part 2, I will explain how Force took advantage of his new found power to go further into the Silk Road candy store.